mesmith wrote:
I wonder what the difference between the $40 test and the $155 test? That seems like quite a significant difference in cost?
That is a great question. If I lived in Salt Lake City (SLC), I would check the facilities out and give you my recommendation. Since, I don't live in SLC, here are a few of my thoughts. There are three main factors that influence the price here in Portland. I would assume that they are similar in SLC.
1. The VO2 Testing Equipment. Technology advances have produced newer VO2 testing equipment that is less expensive to purchase and operate with a much high quality of results than equipment produced 10 years ago. Facilities with older equipment, tend to charge more because their equipment was more expensive to purchase 10 years ago. Currently, excellent VO2 testing equipment can be purchased for about $15,000. Compare that with $150,000 equipment in the 90's. Companies that produce equipment with the latest technology, such as MedGraphics, have great equipment with high quality results and much better testor comfort than older equipment. Look for a testing facility with newer equipment. (One of the hospitals here in Oregon is using equipment that is connected to an old IBM PC (1981) with a 10meg hard drive! They charge $550 for a VO2 test! In the 90's, I used this facility for my own personal VO2 test. Since I found a facility with the latest test equipment, and $355 cheaper, I don't use this facility anymore!)
2. Administrator Credentials - The test administrator's credentials are important. Usually, the credentials will influence the test price. In Portland (
Clearwater Chiropractic & Massage Clinic), a doctor administers the test ($195). In Seattle (
Real Rehab Physical Therapy), a Physical Therapist administers the test ($40 + 95). The testor should have plenty of experience with administering the tests.
There is a Fitness Club here in Portland that has
ANY personal trainer available administer the VO2 test. They charge $145 for the VO2 test. They have great testing equipment, but the test administrators aren't trained to administer the test properly. After reviewing half a dozen test results from this facility, I encourage people to not waste their money and just go to Clearwater. At Clearwater, I know they are going to get great test results every time!
3. Facility Size - The size of the facility effects the price. The larger the facility the higher the price. Doctor's offices and fitness clubs tend to have better prices than hospitals.
There are a lot of places that claim they will administer a VO2 test for you, but in Portland, most of them do not give you the results that you need. There is only one place in Portland that I recommend to get a VO2 Test done and that place is
Clearwater Chiropractic & Massage Clinic. Now, you are probably saying: "Eric, I am not going to fly to Portland to get a $195 VO2 Test". I agree, I don't expect you to. But, on my website
http://www.stressthenrest.com/ATTesting.htm, there is some information on the testing that may help you decide which testing facility in Salt Lake City is going to work for you. In addition, there is a real VO2 Test results chart posted here:
http://www.stressthenrest.com/VO2%20Testing/VO2TestCaloriesVsHeartRate01.pdf. I would suggest that you print off the test results and take it with you to the testing facility. Ask to see a sample report from the testing facility and see if you are getting the same information as my chart. If you are not, then try a different facility.
Once someone finds a VO2 testing facility that produces good results, please post it on the discussion board, so others can use it.Here is the bottom line information that you need in order to start maximizing your performance with a heart rate monitor.
1. Number of total calories being utilized at each heart rate (bpm)
2. Number of fat calories being utilized at each heart rate (bpm)
3. Heart rate where your body stops using fat calories and only uses sugar.
With this data, you can determine:
1. Where you are utilizing the highest percentage of body fat. This is where you train to lose body fat.
2. Where you are utilizing the lowest percentage of body fat. This is where you train to improve your speed.
3. Where you are utilizing 50% body fat and 50% sugar. This is where you train to improve your endurance. (Please note: It takes an experienced person to determine your actual endurance training heart rate range. The 50/50 is only a generic example. Your range will probably be different. This is why it is important to get the correct VO2 test results.)
You might even want to invite someone from the testing facility to come talk to your group and show you what they can do for your group. They should give your group a discount. The SeattleFit group gets about a 30% discount at their testing facility. I believe that the SeattleFit members pay a first time $40 fee for the testing mask and $95 for each test.
Keep those questions coming....
You can always email me (
Eric@StressThenRest.com) directly if you individual questions.
Eric